*tapping microphone*
“My name is Jenny. I’m a recovering first-born people-pleasing rule follower.”
“Hello, Jenny.”
In November, I’ll be forty. Yup. Forty years old, and I’m still growing up! It’s hard.
Here are the challenges:
1. First born: I know, not all first borns are like me, but a lot of us are used to coordinating things, being in control, helping other people fix things, etc. I never really thought of myself as a control freak, but over the last couple years I’ve come to see that letting go of control is hard for me.
2. People-pleasing: Sometimes I take my people pleasing too far and 1) try to fix things when people aren’t looking for that and 2) try to make everybody happy. Obviously that is not possible. It’s just a fact of life.
3. Rule follwer: I’ve come to realize that as a natural rule follower, I tend to follow the rules and not think about the why of the rules. Not in a rebellious way, but to think for myself, make decisions for myself, and trust that my decision is a good one even if others disagree (see #2). I’ve thought about this a little here and there, but recently because of my job with Home Educating Family, I’ve come to see that I’m used to doing what I’m told and going with the flow (see #2 again) instead of thinking about issues. The magazine article “They Smile, but Do They Laugh?” got in my face about doing my own thinking. You see, the reason for the article is to get people to think and discern instead of just going along with something because everyone else is.
The hard thing is that now I’m realizing this, I see two things: 1) Thinking on my own is hard work and 2) fibromyalgia and stress have made it harder for me to think.
So, here I am approaching forty and realizing I drive my husband crazy, sometimes make my sister (who’s pretty good at not saying anything) laugh because I’m so ridiculous, and probably frustrate quite a few other people. Add in my left-brainedness, and, well, I’ve got a lot of work to do at letting go!
There is also a lot of guilt that comes with each of these personality traits. I feel guilty if I didn’t do something just right–even really small things that don’t matter. I feel guilty if I know someone isn’t going to like a decision I made. I feel guilty if my kids didn’t get enough vegetables one day. I feel guilty if I asked too much of someone. I feel guilty, guilty, guilty.
That’s not healthy.
What can I do? Fix my eyes on Jesus, the Author and Finisher of my faith. Follow God’s Word. Trust the Holy Spirit to guide me in what is right.
And that’s hard. Sure, I can type it, but to live it and believe it is hard for a people-pleaser!
I have to continue to practice letting go. (Sarah, I’m not going to straighten those pictures at your house anymore.)
Are there any other recovering first-born people-pleasing rule followers out there? Give me a holler in the comments below? Are you NOT that way? Leave your favorite tip about letting go!

September 22, 2012 at 3:50 PM
I hold a unique place in my family. Middle child, yes right between two others, and a first born. How, according to a book I read about birth order, the fact that I am the only girl made me a first born. I guess I got the best of both world, enough first born to take life serious and work hard, follow the rules and be a fixer of all things. BUT then there is the middle child in me, that rebel who got over looked A LOT while growing up would raised herself most the time while energy and attention when to the ones 5-4 years older than me and the ones 5-6 years young! Results…First to move out at 18 and pay my own way to college, first to get a speeding ticket…so what does that say about me…quite a bit. Life has taught me to enjoy who I am, and let the chips fall where they may! Enjoy holding on to 39 a few more weeks…we will have you a long distance 40 bash…
September 22, 2012 at 3:52 PM
September 22, 2012 at 8:26 PM
Love this and can so relate to not thinking but just following what I am told. Been working on that for the past couple of years and I’m sure I’ll be working on it for my lifetime.
September 22, 2012 at 9:10 PM
I agree! I will probably be working on it for the rest of my lifetime, too.
September 23, 2012 at 12:29 AM
As a first-born rule follower and independent thinker I feel your pain! I too like the fix things that no one asked me to and can so relate! I’m still growing-up, and learning as well… a life-long process, to be sure!
September 23, 2012 at 12:31 AM
Thanks for the encouragement , Felice. I think you’re a very good example.